by Jesse Enloe - May 4, 1998
The 1868 Supreme
In Texas v. White there were two questions put before the Supreme Court to answer. The question of whether Texas annexation was legal/lawful was NOT one of the questions. The case dealt with the legality of the sale of
The reason that the legality of the Annexation of Texas was not a question in Texas v. White, and has never been ruled on in any other case the Federal Court or Supreme Court has ever heard is that the Federal Courts do not have jurisdiction to answer that question. It is a POLITICAL QUESTION that can only be answered by Texas and/or the Congress of the United States. In 1868 the question was put to the Congress of the U.S. and it was sent to the Judiciary Committee where it was tabled or "put in a drawer somewhere" and NEVER answered.
The headlines that "Texas Annexation was Legal," that are appearing in many newspapers, do not appear to be an accurate rendition of Judge Friedman's decision. Because of the fact that he quoted Texas v. White shows only that he is bound by this Supreme Court decision that "Secession is not legal." This, though not relevant to the question of the annexation being lawful, is also a flawed ruling if the principle is true that "All Political Power is Inherent in the People," which is stated in the Declaration of Independence for the United States of America and in every Texas Constitution ever written.
So, let's address the real question: Was the Annexation of Texas legal? On October 16, 1843 Secretary of State A.P. Upshur, at the direction of President John Tyler, wrote to
This shows that the men of the government of the United States understood that the only proper and lawful way for one nation to deal with another is by treaty. That principle is still part of International Law today. And the only way for the legislature of the United States to approve a treaty is by a two thirds vote of the Senate, per the Constitution for the United States of America.
The treaty was presented to the Senate in 1844 and was DEFEATED by a vote of 35 to 16. The following year, in 1845, the House of Representatives entered into the record a "Resolution of Annexation." The House of Representatives has no authority to initiate a matter of foreign affairs. After passing the resolution, the United States declared that Texas was a "State of the Union." This was an unlawful, fraudulent process which has been questioned since it was done, but the United States has failed at every turn to answer the questions regarding the unlawful process it used to acquire Texas. Secretary Upshur's own letter is evidence that a "Resolution" is NOT the proper and lawful way to annex a Nation as a State!
The question of the "perpetual nature of the union of American States," addressed in Texas v. White, is one that is irrelevant to the question of the lawful status of Texas since Texas was never lawfully joined to the Union. It is a maxim of law that anything done by fraud is void from the beginning.
Each person needs to think for themselves and answer the question for themselves. The United States is not going to answer the question of the Legality of Annexation. They have had 153 years, since 1845, and have not answered it yet.
Consider these questions:
Is it an established principle in United States Law and International Law that Nations deal with each other only by treaty?
Per the Constitution of the United States, how are treaties approved?
Was a Treaty of Annexation of Texas approved by the Unites States Senate? Look at the United States Congressional Records and the Constitution for the United States of America for the answers to these questions. Do not rely on anyone from the Government or anyone else. Answer the questions yourselves. There is only one possible conclusion. Texas was NOT annexed to the United States as a State by proper lawful action.
In summary, the ruling of Judge Friedman is as void as the 1868 Supreme Court decision and the annexation process itself, because it is all based on elected officials acting outside their delegated authority, which means those actions are fraudulent and unlawful. And more to the point, Judge Friedman did not say that Texas was legally annexed!
Many of the People of Texas know that Texas was never lawfully made a part of the United States of America, and the Republic of Texas not only continues to exist, it is Alive and Well! The People of the Republic of Texas remain committed to the Peaceful and Lawful Restoration of Texas as an Independent and Sovereign Nation.
Republic of Texas Former Official website
Republic of Texas Former Official website